Psychiatric Considerations In Rheumatoid Arthritis
Medical Clinics of North America 39: 1955; 447-458
View Original Source →Abstract
Since it is apparent that disruption of a meaningful relationship with resulting emotional trauma frequently precedes an attack of arthritis, the first task of therapy from the psychiatric point of view will be to restore the patient’s sense of security. This can be done by establishing a positive contact with him, which may follow easily as a corollary of the usual medical treatment, especially if the disease is acute and hospitalization is necessary. This contact does much to gratify dependent needs by attention to the patient’s comfort through medication and nursing care. It is possible that some of the spontaneous remissions of the disease, so characteristic in the early stages, have some bearing on the patient’s ability, with the aid of his contact with the doctor, or through other means, to restore his sense of security by replacing the disrupted relationship with another. Such a substitution for the lost relationship cannot be considered in any sense to constitute a “cure” from the psychologic standpoint. In carefully chosen cases it is feasible to attempt by means of psychotherapy to resolve this peculiar dependent relationship on the physician. In view of the depth of the psychopathology, which has its roots in the very early life experiences of the patient, this will be a lengthy process. Efforts of this sort would seem to carry a possible favorable prognosis in those patients who are treated early in the course of the disease before extensive, irreversible joint damage has occurred. However, the remissions that are observed in rheumatoid arthritis late in the disease give a clue that psychotherapy may occasionally be useful in such cases as well. At any rate it is logical in patients highly vulnerable to stress to resolve psychic conflicts as fully as one attempts to treat physical and dietary defects.
Case Details
Personal Characteristics
A young woman in her early 20s, had a moderately severe attack of generalized rheumatoid arthritis following entrance to college, which eventually necessitated withdrawal and hospitalization. There had been a possible mild attack of joint disease in childhood. The patients father became ill with postencephalitic parkinsonism shortly after her birth and soon left the family. The patients mother had to support herself and the patient and often left her with neighbors or, later, alone during the day.
Clinical Characteristics
The patients sense of insecurity was increased by visits to her father whose strange appearance and behavior frightened her. During therapy she showed marked anxiety, sitting rigidly on the edge of her chair, almost unable to speak unless supported by the doctors conversation. On several occasions it was noted that her anxiety was intensified even more and a few days later she would report a sequence of events following an argument with her mother, or overhearing her mother argue with someone else. These events produced severe tension and anxiety, and were followed in 12 to 24 hours by an exacerbation of joint swelling, especially of the knees, the whole episode subsiding in 3 or 4 days.
Remission Characteristics
Several such episodes were observed. During treatment she attended secretarial school. She discontinued therapy when she graduated and obtained a position in a doctors office. She returned 3 years later to report that she had been well until her mother objected to her engagement, when joint symptoms reappeared for a short time.
Treatment & Mechanisms
Proposed Remission Mechanisms
Not discussed
Clinical Treatment
Therapy, medication
Non-Clinical Treatment
Psychotherapy
Additional Notes
The patients sense of security was increased by visits to her father whose strange appearance and behavior frightened her. During therapy she showed marked anxiety, sitting rigidly on the edge of her chair, almost unable to speak unless supported by the doctors conversation. On several occasions it was noted that her anxiety was intensified even more and a few days later she would report a sequence of events following an argument with her mother, or overhearing her mother argue with someone else. These events produced severe tension and anxiety, and were followed in 12 to 24 hours by an exacerbation of joint swelling, especially of the knees, the whole episode subsiding in 3 or 4 days.