Verruca Plana Of The Face Treated By Posthypnotic Suggestion
Archives of Dermatology and Syphilology 60: 1949; 1222-1224
View Original Source →Abstract
The literature on the suggestion therapy of warts has been reviewed and the areas of general agreement among the various investigators have been noted. With due consideration to the rate of spontaneous recoveries (as near as this can be determined by studying large groups of patients with warts), the cure of warts can be brought about by psychological means generally associated with the term suggestion. Some authors go so far as to imply that this is the most important factor underlying the successful treatment of warts by x-ray, drugs, and even surgery. All agree that in one way or another an affective response must be set up in the patient. An attempt was made to reconsider the work of earlier investigators from the viewpoint of the nature and goal of the personal relationships established. For the most part, they represented a heightening of the authoritarian relationship between doctor and patient in an effort to reproduce clinically some of the psychological factors which obtain in lay healing, e.g., the combination of submission and helplessness on the part of the subject and the aura of omnipotence and infallibility on the part of the healer or healer-symbol. The ritual involved in the various lay approaches and the procedures employed in the medical techniques to effect a cure by suggestion both result in the temporary suspension of the discriminative, critical, and evaluative faculties of the patient in favor of certain emotional reactions engendered by the situation. These reactions are as yet not very clearly defined. The considerations here presented warrant the further exploratory use of hypnosis as a procedure incorporating many of the elements that appear to be involved in the various accounts of the cure of warts by suggestion.
Case Details
Personal Characteristics
21-year-old unmarried woman
Clinical Characteristics
Flat warts on the right side of her chin, spread rapidly, involved most of the face, lesions also present on the forehead, the anterior portion of the scalp and the sides of the neck
Remission Characteristics
Two weeks after the last consultation, all verrucae had disappeared
Treatment & Mechanisms
Proposed Remission Mechanisms
Posthypnotic suggestion
Clinical Treatment
Fractional doses of roentgen rays for acne vulgaris, electrodesiccation, injections of bismuth subsalicylate in oil, applications of peeling ointments and solid carbon dioxide, use of lotions in combination with ultraviolet irradiation, oral administration of bismuth (sobisminol mass), local use of a 20% solution of podophyllin in acetone
Non-Clinical Treatment
Imagining her face was covered by cold compresses and was beginning to itch and tingle before bedtime each night
Additional Notes
The patient was referred to Dr. Ralph R. Greenson, certified by the American Board of Psychiatry. She saw Dr. Greenson only three times, at weekly intervals.